OPINION: Mansfield town centre will never recapture its glory days of old, but we can still turn things around

The state of Mansfield’s town centre and its long-term commercial viability has been stirring up plenty of debate in recent weeks.

Whatever your stance on this particular hot potato, it’s fair to say Mansfield has seen better days.

It’s a bit of a sight for sore eyes for locals new to the area and an even more painful one for those of us who have called Mansfield our home for decades.

I recently spoke to a friend who has lived in Mansfield all his life who actually described being visibly upset by the current state of the town.

Mansfield town centre has seen better days with footfall from shoppers on the decreaseplaceholder image
Mansfield town centre has seen better days with footfall from shoppers on the decrease

There’s been a lot of reasons suggested for the worrying decline, with many saying expensive car parking, lack of shops and unpleasant social conditions such as homelessness and anti-social behaviour are to blame.

The decrease in choice is certainly an issue as more and more vacant shops pop up and people opt to go elsewhere to more fashionable locations.

But, for me, there is one simple factor behind this trend and that is convenience.

The digital revolution has simply changed how consumers do things now. There’s no need to go into town to buy a new item of clothing, to pick up some food for tea or purchase a new CD any more.

Everything we need in terms of consumer items is online. There's an infinite world of music and films available to stream and there’s all the clothing items in the world available at the touch of a button. And best of all - best for shoppers that is - it can all be done without ever leaving your settee.

In general we all expect life to just be way easier than it was 25 years ago. We don’t want to have to fight for a narrow car park space, we don’t want to have to try and find loose change to pay for the car park and we certainly don’t want to go around loads of different shops in the cold and rain when we can just get our stuff sorted while we watch tv.

For me town centres have to adapt to these changes if they are to become viable again. Trying to attract more national chain shops into the town almost feels like fighting a losing battle.

We have to give people what they can’t get online, and no, that doesn’t mean more hairdressers, such as social life attractions.

Mansfield Mayor Andy Abrahams told me this week how work was going on to ‘create jobs and improve the look and feel of our town’ and how the council “will always work with independent businesses in the town to support them to be successful.”

More high quality cafes, restaurants, sweet treat places and music venues would certainly be a step in the right direction to improving the town centre vibe and giving people a reason to come on in.

Local businesses need to be supported, and that also means budding entrepreneurs looking to get up and running.

It would be great to see some units or space set aside for locally themed pop up shops. There could be a different theme each month to showcase locally produced artisan food, home-made seasonal clothing items and local bakeries for example.

These shops would be run by local people and showcase what is good about Mansfield. They might not prove to be highly profitable ventures but it would certainly help to promote local pride.

News this week that the old BHS is set for a big revamp is very welcome. It’s been a long time coming and turning the eyesore into a new food hall and leisure area is certainly a step in the right direction.

Done right, food halls and indoor markets can add plenty of value to a town - as the revamped indoor market over at Sutton shows.

Arresting the decline in town centre footfall isn’t just as simple as chucking a load of money into the pot.

The start truth is Mansfield town centre will never get back to what it was, those days are long gone. However, with a bit of imagination, careful planning and the desire to bring about change, it’s not too late for Mansfield to flip things on its head.

Tell us your thoughts on the state of Mansfied and what needs to be done. Join the debate on our social media channels.

News you can trust since 1952
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice