'With the amount of police that turned up we knew it was big' - witness describes the dramatic night when the Black Panther was finally caught in Mansfield

It was supposed to be a relaxing night chatting with a mate over a bag of fish and chips.

But that’s not how it turned out for Rainworth resident Paul Cullen who instead found himself unwittingly caught up in the capture of Britain’s most wanted man nearly 50 years ago.

Psychopathic killer, Donald Neilson, was captured in Rainworth by police officers PC White and PC MacKenzie four decades ago.placeholder image
Psychopathic killer, Donald Neilson, was captured in Rainworth by police officers PC White and PC MacKenzie four decades ago.

The former postman, who was just 18 at the time, had been outside The Junction Fish Bar with friend Derrick Smart when all hell broke loose in the quiet Mansfield village on the night of December 11, 1975.

It was here that vicious murderer Donald Neilson, known under his tabloid title as The Black Panther because of tendency to wear a black balaclava, was finally snared after a trail of terror which left four people dead.

The Junction in Rainworth, where 'The Black Panther' Donald Neilson was finally caught.placeholder image
The Junction in Rainworth, where 'The Black Panther' Donald Neilson was finally caught.

Violent Neilson was caught after being randomly stopped by police officers Tony White and Stuart Mackenzie who had spotted him behaving strangely.

But the serial killer didn’t go down quietly and, after taking both officers hostage and forcing them to go on a drive at gunpoint, he was eventually overpowered by the pair and bystanders when the car came to a screeching halt on Southwell Road East.

For Paul it’s a night of drama that has naturally lived long in his memory.

“The Ford Escort police car had been coming down the road when it slammed on its brakes and must have slid about three or four yards,” he told Chad.

“Then there was this loud gunshot and one of the officers either wound down the window or opened the door and shouted ‘we’ve got an armed man here’.

“Our fish and chips went up in the air and I ran up the road to the phone box to ring 999. It was all out of the blue, and by the time I’d got back he was still struggling on the floor.

“He had been overpowered and had been handcuffed to the railings next to the fish shop, but he was still trying to get away. The buttons of his jacket came undone and I saw bullets strapped to his belt and knives inside his jacket.

“There was also a big sawn-off shotgun lying in the middle of the road, an inspector picked it up with a white handkerchief.

“I think about how lucky everyone was, it was frightening when that gun went off, it could have killed anyone.

“Nobody knew who he was. This happened on the Thursday night and it wasn’t until the Saturday that we were told. There were journalists everywhere.

“Everybody was shocked, but with the amount of police that turned up we knew it was big.”

Savage Nielson, a 39-year-old builder from Bradford, had become headline news across Britain when his taste for burglary turned into armed robberies and then murder.

During the robbery of three post offices in 1974, he shot dead two sub-postmasters and the husband of a sub-postmistress.

But it was his final meticulously-planned crime that ensured his reputation as one of Britain’s most evil killers, when he kidnapped 17-year-old Lesley Whittle from her Shropshire home.

An heiress to a fortune, Neilson had been hatching his plan for three years and demanded a £50,000 ransom for her safe return.

He kept her at the bottom of a drain shaft in a park in Stafford, naked with a hood over her head and tethered by a wire around her neck.

After the ransom drop failed, Lesley’s body was found still hanging from the wire nearly two months later.

Following his arrest in Rainworth, his fingerprints matched those found in the shaft.

Neilson, who was convicted of all four murders and given a whole-life tariff, died in prison in 2011 aged 75.

For Mr Cullen though, the maximum jail sentence did not provide closure.

“Even when he was in jail, he still made threats that he would come and get everybody so I thought about it quite a bit,” he said. “He was in jail but we were worried he’d get out, or if he had an accomplice.

“Nobody ever knew what he did with the money he stole, so nobody knew if there was somebody else outside of jail. I think we were all sort of relieved when he died in 2011. I used to have nightmares about it after it all happened, but not so much now.

“I feel both lucky and unlucky to have been there that night.”

News you can trust since 1952
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice