Opinion: The training chasm and the trap of ‘Unsuited’ mental health care

Opinion: The training chasm and the trap of ‘Unsuited’ mental health care

When you spend years studying health and social care at undergraduate and postgraduate level, you develop certain expectations about how care should work.

Alex Crawshaw has first-hand experience of mental health care.placeholder image
Alex Crawshaw has first-hand experience of mental health care. | Alex Crawshaw

You learn about person-centred practice, safeguarding, communication, psychology, social determinants of health and the importance of treating people with dignity.

Then you experience the system from the other side of the desk. That is when the gap between theory and reality can become difficult to ignore.

As a service user in Mansfield and various places in Nottinghamshire, I have sometimes found myself questioning whether the people working within care environments have been given the training, support and development necessary to deal with the complexity of the people they are supporting.

That is not necessarily an indictment of individual workers. In many cases, it may be an indictment of the system around them.

Academic models can make healthcare and social care appear remarkably logical. Real human beings do not work like that.

People arrive with trauma, anxiety, behavioural difficulties, physical health problems, communication difficulties and complicated histories. Sometimes they cannot explain what is wrong. Sometimes their behaviour is the communication.

My own education has actually made me more conscious of this gap. The more I have studied health and social care, psychology and human behaviour, the more I have realised that there are rarely simple answers when dealing with another human being.

Sometimes individuals are responsible for poor practice. Accountability matters. But we also need to ask what happens when a sector struggles to recruit and retain people, when staff are under pressure and when training becomes something that has to be completed rather than something that has to be understood.

The real question is whether we are giving people the preparation and support required to do an incredibly difficult job properly. There is a difference between knowing about care and knowing how to care.

Training should not simply be about completing modules. It should involve reflection, supervision, practical learning, feedback and opportunities to develop.

And perhaps most importantly, staff need to feel able to ask questions themselves. My own experience has also taught me something uncomfortable: communication is not a one-way process.

I have spent years learning about health and social care, but I have also had to learn how to communicate better myself. I have learned to listen and asking questions can be more useful than immediately offering an answer.

A care worker is not simply a job title. They are a human being working within a system, often under considerable pressure. If we want better care, we have to create the conditions in which better care is possible.

That means taking training seriously and creating a culture where communication is valued alongside compliance.

People receiving care often know where the system is failing. Their experiences should not automatically be dismissed as complaints. They can provide valuable information about what needs to change.

Our country deserves health and social care services where people are treated as individuals rather than problems to be processed.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1952
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice