Mansfield Town player ratings: Do YOU agree with these ratings for the Stags against Swindon?

Mansfield Town pundit Martin Shaw has given us his player ratings for the Stags side who were beaten 3-1 at home by Swindon Town.
Mansfield Town vs Swindon Town - Danny Rose of Mansfield Town - Pic By James WilliamsonMansfield Town vs Swindon Town - Danny Rose of Mansfield Town - Pic By James Williamson
Mansfield Town vs Swindon Town - Danny Rose of Mansfield Town - Pic By James Williamson

Danny Rose, who scored the late consolation, was named Martin’s man-of-the-match, but do you agree?

Martin Shaw’s player ratings:

Logan 6 Not at fault for the goals in our opinion. One mistake early on when he got out of jail. One good save with his legs in the first half.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

White 4 Lost his man for both first half goals. Terrible comeback game from injury. We would be tempted to bring in the solid Bennett at Barnet.

Pearce 5 Below par. Perhaps harshly penalised for the penalty.

Mirfin 5 A few headers straight up in the air. Part of a poor defence.

Hunt 5 Some poor balls forward. Summed up the team’s lack of confidence when he had a chance to shoot and laid the ball off.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Butcher 5 Displayed a total lack of confidence, too often playing the ball backwards rather than forwards. Harshly received a few boos in the first half for a misplaced pass, but responded with some good challenges.

Atkinson 5 Completely anonymous apart from a one-two with MacDonald to set up a shot. Subbed at half-time.

MacDonald 5.5 His silly and unnecessary foul resulted in the first goal, which set the tone for game. Worked hard as always and provided a fine cross for the consolation goal.

Mellis 5 Started the first half brightly, but completely faded after that.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Spencer 6 Two good turns in the first half, and one fine shot that brought a good save. Unlucky to be subbed at half-time.

Rose 6 Took his goal well. Good flick on for Spencer’s chance. Some poor efforts too, and handled well by the Swindon centre halves.

Subs:

Angol (for Spencer, 46 mins) 6 One fine effort with a venomous shot. One other effort saved on the line. Set up one chance for Rose.

Sterling-James (for Atkinson, 46 mins) 5 Had a couple of chances to shoot and instead laid the ball off. Had little impact.

Have your say below, on our Facebook page or by email at [email protected]