Player ratings: How Martin Shaw rated the Stags players against Portsmouth

Mansfield Town pundit Martin Shaw has give us his player ratings for the Stags side who lost 1-0 to Portsmouth on Saturday.

Sunday, 30th April 2017, 8:41 pm
Updated Tuesday, 9th May 2017, 6:50 pm
Mansfield Town v Portsmouth. Alex MacDonald takes a first half shot at goal.

Alex MacDonald caught Martin’s eye with a man-of-the-match rating.


Sign up to our daily newsletter

The i newsletter cut through the noise

White 7 - Good game. Got forward well in the second half.

Bennett 7 - Missed a chance early on. Defended well throughout.

Pearce 7 - Another battling performance.

Benning 7 - Some good attacking in the second half.

Collins 7 - Good game. One outstanding run forward.

Whiteman 7 - One good shot, one super cross for MacDonald’s header. Good ball forward for Coulthirst in the first half.

Byrom 7 - Some good set pieces.

MacDonald 8 - Outstanding second half, absolutely gave his all, typified by winning both contested drop-balls. Like a terrier. Finishing let him down including one great chance from a header. One piece of sloppy play in the first half gifted Portsmouth a chance.

Coulthirst 6.5 - Some great approach play and turns, but missed a few chances.

D.Rose 6.5 - The foul on him should have resulted in a red card. Two weak shots at the keeper, and a header over the bar.


Green (for Collins, 68 mins) - Missed a golden chance.

Taft (for D. Rose, 83 mins).

Hoban (for MacDonald, 86 mins).

Have your saw on our Facebook page or by email [email protected]