AFC Mansfield were beaten 2-1 at Handsworth Parramore on Boxing Day.
The Bulls hopes of some festive cheer disappeared after just three minutes as hosts Handsworth unlocked AFC’s defence through Alex Rippon.
Another run and cross from Buttle two minutes later found the head of Aaron Moxam, but this time Jason White had it covered.
The visitors then mounted an attack of their own when Jimmy Ghaichem fired wide on eight minutes.
Moxam looked well offside on 10 minutes and even he looked round for a flag, that hesitation allowed White to get down to save with questions being asked of the assistant referee.
A period of pressure around the 25-minute mark saw at least four blocked efforts on the Mansfield goal. The ball then bounced in front of Danny Patterson who should have hooked it away to safety but he completely missed the ball.
Waiting goal side was Moxam and his 36th goal of the season was handed to him on a plate, although the finish was still top drawer.
The second half started much brighter for The Bulls and Ghaichem drove his cross across the face of Joe Green’s goal with just a touch needed.
Handsworth broke quickly and if it hadn’t been for a telling interception from Joe Cheeseman, on for the injured Grant Allott, the hosts could have increased their lead.
Fearon’s cross on the hour mark was met by Cheeseman, Green easily held his looping header.
A double substitution on 65 minutes with Bradshaw and Karkach coming on for D’Laryea and Cullingworth saw the visitors adopt a more attacking stance.
A combination of Williams, Bradshaw and Dudley set Matty Plummer clear in the box but his shot was always rising on 70 minutes.
Jimmy Ghaichem wriggled into the boxonly to see an arm across his face stop his run and the referee immediately signalled for a penalty.
Some histrionics from keeper Green saw him booked but his actions put White off and he skied his spot kick over the bar.
More ridiculous behaviour from the keeper and others sparked a little melee but the referee decided to book Ollie Fearon for getting involved and letting the instigators off scot free and his explanation after the game of the incident was weak.
A scything tackle on Lynton Karkach on 88 minutes brought the AFC goal.
A great delivery from Ryan Williams was met by a Chris Timons glancing header and left Green rooted to the spot.
Moxam then missed a sitter in front of goal but somehow managed to fire five yards wide of the target with just the keeper to beat.
Handsworth were now employing some of the dark arts of football to keep The Bulls at bay but unfortunately the referee allowed them a certain artistic licence in their marking techniques.
There was more drama before the end when Fearon got a powerful header in which cannoned of the crossbar with Green well beaten.
It was the proverbial game of two halves but, with Handsworth averaging over three goals a game, AFC did well to restrict them in the secnd half and with a little more luck could have gotten something out of the game.
Handsworth Parramore: Green, Ludlam, Smythe, Claisse, Harcourt, Griffiths , Rippon, Fletcher, Froggatt, Moxam, Buttle (Eades 89). Subs not used: Tootle, Ward, Starosta & Sneath
AFC Mansfield: White, Plummer, Dudley, Allott (Cheeseman 45), Timons, D’Laryea (Karkach 65), Williams, Patterson (C), Fearon, Cullingworth (Bradshaw 65), Ghaichem. Subs not used: Naylor & Paling.
Referee: Mr Christian Silcock
Assistants: Mr Jamie O’Connor & Mr David Maran
MoM: AFC Mansfield – Danny Patterson, Handsworth Parramore: Danny Buttle