Mansfield Town player ratings: Do YOU agree with these ratings for the Stags in their 3-1 win against Notts County?

Danny Rose
Danny Rose
Share this article

Mansfield Town pundit Martin Shaw has given us his player ratings for the Stags side who defeated leaders Notts County 3-1 in a thrilling derby win on Saturday.

Two-goal Danny Rose caught Martin’s eye with a man-of-the-match rating, but do you agree?

Match report

Rose ecstatic after double helps sink Notts County

Steve Evans post-match reaction

Kevin Nolan praises Stags

Martin Shaw’s player ratings:

Logan 6 - Got a hand on the free kick for the goal but didn’t keep it out. Didn’t have any other shots to save. One punch away from a free kick.

Anderson 8 - Impressed hugely stepping in at right back. One fine block on a shot to deflect it over the bar. One particularly good cross.

Pearce 8 - Very good game, winning almost everything. At the other end, should have scored with a header and set up a good chance for Hemmings.

Mirfin 8 - Important clearance off the line. Solid game. A couple of minor mistakes.

Hunt 7 - Solid at left back and warranting his place ahead of Benning for his defending. One fine block on a shot to deflect it over the bar.

Potter 7 - Had started the game well, but had to go off with an injury on 33 minutes.

Atkinson 7 - Workmanlike performance as Mansfield had more bite in midfield.

Butcher 7 - Very solid game, especially in the second half putting his foot on the ball, playing simple passes, and getting stuck in.

MacDonald 7.5 - Fine game on the left though should have scored near the end, and was denied by a great save from his free kick in the first half. Some good set pieces.

Hemmings 7 - Worked tirelessly and was unlucky that the second goal wasn’t his. Missed two good chances in the first half.

Rose 9 - Quite outstanding. Scored two, then his cross resulted in the third goal, also set up a great chance for MacDonald with a fabulous touch.

Sub Sterling-James (for Potter, 33 mins) 7 - Fine cross for the second goal. Slotted in well in place of Potter on the right.

Have your say below, on our Facebook page or by email at