'It felt like I'd been shot': Mansfield Town’s Baily Cargill looks back on nine-month injury absence that became the 'toughest part of his career'
Baily Cargill is working back to match fitness after a long nine months away from the pitch.
The defender, who first signed for Mansfield Town in 2023, has not pulled on the amber and blue kit since February this year.
Cargill was forced out of action after suffering a serious hamstring injury, which ended up unfolding into further complications and left fans wondering for months on end when he would return.
Earlier this week, the 31-year-old made a media appearance and spoke about his long, gruelling journey to recovery.


Cargill confirmed he was back in training with the rest of team and was scheduled to undergo tests this week to assess his progress.
“I trained yesterday and absolutely loved it,” he said during Mansfield Town’s press conference on Tuesday. “I’ve been missing playing, I love the game.”
His phased return to getting back on the pitch is being handled carefully. But while the end of this difficult chapter is finally nearing its end, Cargill hasn’t forgotten just how hard it’s been.
“It’s been pretty complicated, it’s not been as straightforward as I’d have hoped,” he said. “It’s easily been the toughest part of my career – nine months since I played a proper game.


“It’s been really challenging mentally but I’ve learned a lot about myself as a person. Sticking with it, there’s been ups and downs but fingers crossed, I feel like I’m near the end of it now.”
Cargill’s injury occurred during Stags’ 2-1 defeat against Peterborough last season in February. He knew at the time it wasn’t a minor issue but little could have prepared him for the complications that followed.
“I was running back to try and stop the striker getting a cross in. I tried to nick the ball away and as I stretched my leg out, I felt a pop and instantly knew it wasn’t good. It felt like I’d been shot, to be honest,” Cargill reflected.
“I had the scan a couple of days later and I’d ripped the hamstring off the bone. So I had to have an operation a week later to reconstruct the hamstring and re-attach it to where it should be.
“The rehab for that initial injury went quite well. I was always planning to get back for the first day of pre-season and that happened – I didn’t really have any hiccups with that.
“I got back fit and felt really good in pre-season, I felt quite strong. But once we got to the end of the really tough bit of pre-season, I felt my hamstring again. It was a little bit lower down this time and that was supposed to be a pretty simple four-week recovery but maybe I didn’t rehab the initial injury as well as I thought I did.”
Cargill’s hopes of starting the 2026/27 season with his teammates were dashed around the time Stags played Alfreton Town, he said, when the intensity ahead of the start of League One action picked up.
What was initially meant to be a straightforward recovery turned into another spell of months on the side-lines, before the cause of aggravation was finally outlined.
Cargill explained the difficulties he had been experiencing and what was stopping him from progressing with his recovery.
“I had so many different complications and saw so many different people but I got to the bottom of what the problem was. It took a while to work out why I wasn’t getting back as I should have been.
“The muscle that’s been reattached is never going to be as big as it should be. There are three muscles in your hamstring and the other two are over-compensating for the one that isn’t big enough.
“So it’s been about trying to build that muscle up so the others aren’t over-compensating. I think that’s why I redid the injury in pre-season because the other muscles were over-compensating and struggling to cope. It took a while to find out that was the problem.”
Cargill is now eyeing his return to the pitch with Mansfield Town and says after he re-introduces sprinting into his training, he will look to get some play-time minutes from somewhere in the tank, before finally putting himself in contention for Nigel Clough’s team.