Mansfield: Green light for 52 homes on site of burnt-down school – despite strong objections

Developers have been given permission to build 52 homes on the site of an old Mansfield school that burnt down in 2011.

The small new estate, to be accessed from Princess Avenue and Pump Hollow Lane in Forest Town, is set to be made up of mainly three-bed detached houses, with an additional 18 two-bed homes, where Sherwood Hall School once stood.

The planning application for the site was submitted in 2025 and was granted by Mansfield Council’s planning committee on April 13.

Presenting a report on the suitability of the proposal, planning officer Claire Richards said: “The development gives us the opportunity to improve things, to integrate the site into the wider environment and to contribute to the wider green infrastructure, which could improve the environment for local residents.

The houses will be built on the site of the old Sherwood Hall School. Photo: Googleplaceholder image
The houses will be built on the site of the old Sherwood Hall School. Photo: Google

“It brings with it proper footpaths, managed open space, landscaping and ecological enhancements, which overall strengthen the corridor rather than harm it.

“It is considered that there is no reason 52 dwellings couldn’t be accommodated without harming existing residential amenity.”

The meeting heard that there was only one objection from statutory consultees, with Sport England noting the potential loss of playing fields.

If the fields had been in official use within the past five years, an approved application would have had to be sent to the Secretary of State, but, due to them being out of official use for 14 years, it would not.

The green light has been given for 52 homes to be built on the site of Sherwood Hall School after it was ravaged by fire back in 2011.placeholder image
The green light has been given for 52 homes to be built on the site of Sherwood Hall School after it was ravaged by fire back in 2011.

The meeting also heard that the area is popular with members of the public, but is not an official open space, is not formally accessible to the public, and is only rough grassland with no pitches, goalposts, or land maintenance.

But there were 16 official objections to the plans and two speakers took their turns at the committee meeting to express why they thought the plans were a bad idea.

Marilyn Chamouk said: “This is not just about 52 houses being built on our field.

"Loss of habitat for wildlife, loss of amenities for dog walkers and for the children who play in the area when they’re off school.

"When the schools start to open, the parking is absolutely ridiculous.

“Do we really need 52 more houses using an infrastructure which is already overloaded?

"Most families these days have got two working parents.

"Do we really need another hundred cars bombing up and down our streets?”

Parking in the vicinity of the planned development has previously been a concern for local residents.

The new 2.9-hectare site is next to Abbey Primary School, which opponents said gets very congested around school drop-off and pick-up times.

Ms Chimouk said: “Stuart Avenue can’t take any more cars because of the way that it’s been done.

"The emergency services have a problem when it comes to school opening and school shutting.

“I’ve seen buses where the drivers have just left the bus and walked off because they can’t get around the bends because the parking is not good enough.”

The meeting heard that Nottinghamshire Council’s previous Conservative administration had planned for a ‘parking alleviation scheme’ with parking spaces and a turning circle at the site – but it was never built before Reform took over in May 2025.

The new administration was consulted about the plans, as it looks after the county’s roads, but did not oppose them.

It admitted the school was a problem, but not as a result of the development, and was unlikely to be made materially worse by the proposal.

The county council will retain the land they previously purchased for the alleviation scheme, but it is currently uncertain whether the scheme will proceed.

Ward councillor Angie Jackson (Lab), who said she would not be voting on the proposals, raised concerns about ecology and said the area was used by ‘many, many’ local residents.

She also commented on the potential traffic issues, saying: “When the school was moved to its current site many years ago, the county council assured residents that there would be minimal impact on the traffic flow in that area.

"That turned out to be absolutely not true.

"Residents have been subject to abuse and antisocial behavior by parents parking in and around their homes.

“Notwithstanding the fact that residents still don’t believe that a parking alleviation scheme would alleviate the problems, it is by no means assured.

"Since the change of administration at the county council, we’ve not been able to get any assurance from the current administration that this parking alleviation scheme will go ahead.

“My ask to you is why is this development considered acceptable when a parking alleviation scheme was already required and we’re now asking the residents to suffer the traffic movements of another 52 homes.”

Former county councillor, Coun Nigel Moxon (Con) added: “It’s quite well known that parking on Stuart Avenue around school time is atrocious.

"Quite frankly, it’s a real problem.

“I know people at every school say it’s a problem.

"Well, you haven’t seen Stuart Avenue.

"Fights have broken out, antisocial behavior, people parking and driving over people’s gardens, it is just unbelievable.”

He referenced the fact that the original parking alleviation scheme plan was meant to go hand in hand with any planning application, with any future development paying for the alleviation scheme through Section 106 payments, which developers pay to local authorities as part of the granting of planning permission.

The scheme and this planning application are not connected.

Coun Moxon said: “It’s really, really disappointing to see that they’ve got disconnected somehow.

"My concern and worry is that they are going to forever be disconnected and that the parking alleviation scheme won’t happen.

“If that is the case, then this is just going to make the problem on Stewart Avenue so much worse.”

The council’s legal advisor told the meeting that an obligation cannot be imposed on a future applicant to make good a pre-existing problem.

The application is only an outline, meaning councillors had to consider whether the site could physically accommodate 52 homes with appropriate landscaping and open space.

It was unanimously approved, and exact details on appearance, landscape, scale and layout will be decided at a future date.

News you can trust since 1952
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice