£2.6m repair fund untouched before Mansfield car park collapsed
A sum of £2.6m allocated to repair Mansfield’s Walkden Street car park in 2023 was not touched before the structure collapsed in August.
Mansfield’s Labour portfolio holder for corporate and finance, Coun Craig Whitby, confirmed that the pot of money had been sitting ready to use for more than two years,
But the Labour councillor said he could not answer any other questions due to an ongoing legal wrangle with Tesco – which leased the car park from the council.
At a full Mansfield Council meeting on November 25, Conservative councillor Liz Langrick asked Coun Whitby for an update on the situation.


She initially asked: “Why did it take until 2023 for a full structural survey of Walkden Street Car Park to be undertaken when the need for concrete repairs was identified as far back as 2015?
“A total of £2.35m was then spent in the re-cladding project between 2018 and 2023, which also highlighted structural issues, yet it took until late 2023 for a full structural survey to be actually undertaken.
“That survey then highlighted the need for further structural works to be carried out, with a further £2.627m being committed at that time?
"Shouldn’t a full structural survey have happened 10 years ago?”
In response, Coun Whitby said: “Because of the legal proceedings that started on October 16, 2025, and very clear legal advice, I am not able to go into the historical decision-making you’ve referenced today.
“I appreciate this is not the detailed answer you’ve been looking for, but at this point, commenting any further could genuinely prejudice the council’s position.
"When the legal process allows, I will ensure members receive a full, transparent briefing.
Walkden Street Car Park has been closed since the 2023 structural survey was completed and found that 162 structural defects could pose a risk.
The closure was meant to last for 12 months while the £2.6m repair work was carried out.
But by the time it collapsed on August 30, 2025, Coun Whitby confirmed that not a single spade had hit the ground.
Conservative councillor Nigel Moxon asked: “Can you confirm how much of that work had actually been undertaken prior to the recent collapse?”
Coun Whitby said: “Following the survey, funding was allocated for further works. I can confirm that none of these works were undertaken prior to the recent collapse.
“As with the previous question, the ongoing legal action limits what I can say beyond that.
“I know it’s frustrating to get a restrictive answer, but we do need to handle this carefully to protect the council and the public purse.
“Once it’s appropriate to share more, I will ensure members are updated.”
Following up, Coun Moxon asked if any of the money had been spent at all – even on the cost of surveying or other preparatory works.
Coun Whitby confirmed it had not.
After the collapse, the council decided to demolish the car park and were intending to do so less than two months later on October 20.
But Tesco launched its legal action at the last minute on October 16 to stop the demolition so it could carry out its own investigation into the building’s safety.
A council spokesperson said: “We’re currently in legal discussions with the owner of the car park and as such we feel it is not appropriate to comment at this time.”