Bolsover councillor fears pressure on services and loss of countryside after housing scheme gets go-ahead

A concerned councillor has expressed his disappointment with a decision by Derbyshire planners to give the go-ahead for a controversial housing scheme on open countryside between two villages in Bolsover.

Bolsover Council’s planning committee approved the application from Stuart Hill, of Glapwell Nurseries, for six new homes on land at Hill Top Farm, at New Houghton, with access from the A617 Chesterfield Road, during a meeting on March 18th despite planning officers recommendations that the scheme should be refused.

Coun Tom Kirkham (Lab), who oversees the Ault Hucknall ward, pointed out and echoed concerns that the scheme is contrary to the council’s Local Plan policies and that the site lies on open countryside that currently creates a helpful gap in the land separating the New Houghton and Glapwell villages.

He said: “Residents have contacted me asking why councillors have gone against the advice of planning officers on this decision?

Bolsover District Councillor Tom Kirkhamplaceholder image
Bolsover District Councillor Tom Kirkham

Coum Kirkham added: “In my memory I am only aware of two occasions when councillors have gone against officers’ recommendations and approved planning, and both are on the land between Glapwell and New Houghton.

“This land is outside of the Local Plan and people are concerned that houses like these and others are being built in this area with no improvements to roads or other facilities.”

Coun Kirkham also questioned why Coun John Ritchie (Lab) had to declare an interest and was subsequently not able to vote on the application after he had originally referred the matter to the committee due to concerns over a former bungalow and a farm at the site and in light of a previous application for hotel.

The site, which was once a pig farm, has been subject to previous planning applications including a refused scheme for a hotel and golf course in 1992 which was knocked back over concerns for the countryside, the loss of high grade farm land and the loss of a separation gap between New Houghton and Glapwell.

Pictured is Bolsover District Council's offices at The Arc, in Clowneplaceholder image
Pictured is Bolsover District Council's offices at The Arc, in Clowne

However, a subsequent outline planning application was given planning permission in 1994 for a hotel due to the prospect of a jobs boost which was deemed to outweigh other concerns, and a reserved matters application for a 46-bedroom hotel was approved in 1999, but in 2015 planning permission for 180 homes was refused.

Derbyshire Council’s highways authority raised no objections to the latest scheme for six new homes as long as the visibility splays at the access point are wide enough.

The county council’s highways authority confirmed the existing access can achieve appropriate emerging visibility in both directions on to Chesterfield Road and it is wide enough for the movement of vehicles from both directions.

An environmental health officer also raised no objections in principle but advised the need for a phased contamination and remediation scheme along with restricted construction times.

And Derbyshire Wildlife Trust also requested a Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan from the developers as part of the scheme.

However, concerned council planning officers recommended the scheme be refused after highlighting that the site falls in open countryside between two villages and that this gap serves as a buffer between the residential areas and that the development is not considered to be in a sustainable location.

They also pointed out that the site is excluded from the council’s Local Plan and National Planning Policy Framework and therefore does not meet the necessary criteria for a development in the countryside.

Officers also highlighted the scheme does not meet the policy provisions for open breaks in the land between residential areas and they felt it would have a harmful impact on the openness, character and appearance of the area and that it would conflict with the council’s Local Plan as a whole.

A council officer stated: “Whilst the site may be capable of accommodating six dwellings without causing harm to residential amenity, highway safety or biodiversity, the limited public benefit that would arise from this small number of additional dwellings is not considered sufficient to outweigh the visual harm caused to the character of the landscape and the openness of this important open break, contrary to the requirements of policies.”

However, a number of councillors felt the scheme would not detract from the openness, character and appearance of the countryside and after it was argued that any approval would depart from council policies it was decided that delegated authority would be given to the development management and land charges manager and principal planners to grant planning permission with conditions covering issues raised by consultees.

But after Coun Kirkham raised concerns that the development contradicts the Local Plan and will open up greenfield land for further development and put pressure on local services the application was returned to the planning committee for further consideration and a decision at the March 18 meeting.

A council officer stated: “The current proposal must be considered against the development plan which comprises policies in the current Local Plan and the National Planning Policy Framework.

“The current proposal doesn’t create jobs or boost tourism and as such there are no public benefits which could be considered to outweigh the harm caused to the rural character of the area or the openness of this important open break or allow for residential development in an unsustainable location.”

Planning officers recommended refusal on the grounds that the development is harmful to the character of the landscape and the openness of this designated important open break between settlements.

They felt this harm within the countryside was not outweighed by the limited public benefits that would arise from such a small number of additional dwellings and they argued it does not fall within or near to any of the settlement tiers set out within the spatial strategy policy.

But despite council officers’ recommendations, the planning committee voted, with six councillors in favour and one abstention, to grant planning permission for the applicant to build six new dwellings at the site claiming that the development would not detract from the openness, character and appearance of the countryside.

The approved planning permission was agreed subject to conditions including that details of the layout, appearance, landscaping and scale must be obtained by the council’s planning authority before the development gets underway.

Other conditions include necessary approval for the access visibility splays, a lighting strategy, a Habitat Management and Monitoring Plan and a contamination land assessment.

Related topics:
News you can trust since 1952
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice