'We went into the game with no fear' - How plucky underdogs Mansfield Town gave as good as they got against Peter Shilton's Leicester City in the 1969 FA Cup quarter-final

As the Swinging 60’s drew to a close nothing seemed to inspire Third Division Mansfield Town more than facing a high-profile top flight team in the cup.

Tom Eggleston’s under-rated side had already caused a national sensation in the FA Cup after demolishing a West Ham United team, which included World Cup winners Bobby Moore, Geoff Hurst and Martin Peters, 3-0 in the Fifth Round at Field Mill.

Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.placeholder image
Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.

Next up on the unlikely road to Wembley was fellow top-flight side Leicester City, who arrived in Nottinghamshire on 8th March 1969 knowing they were in for a torrid time.

But, unlike the more fashionable London side, the Filbert Street team showed a firm resolve as future England goalkeeper Peter Shilton marshalled his defence in fine fashion to shut out the Stags.

Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.placeholder image
Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.

City defenders Peter Rodriguez, David Nish, John Sjoberg and Graham Cross certainly helped out their keeper to clinically destroy all that Stags could throw at them as Leicester showed their First Division class to claim a 1-0 win.

It’s a defeat in which full-back Sandy Pate felt the plucky underdogs had given as good as they got.

“We had a fair share of play in that game, but Leicester had a fantastic back four as well as Shilton in goal,” he said.

“It was a very tough physical game and we really pushed Leicester all the way to the end. We had beaten West Ham United in the previous round and we went into this game with no fear. We had a fantastic team spirit, we all worked hard for each other and we really did feel we could win every game.

Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.placeholder image
Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.

“It was a really soft goal that we gave away. We thought our goalkeeper would come and collect the cross but he slipped on the boggy pitch. The pitch was a real quagmire, they were not the nice pitches they are today. It was a really poor goal to concede and naturally we were very disappointed.

“Leicester were a very good side. Rodriguez and Nish were quick and skillful players. Gibson was a Scottish international and was a good player. Lenny Glover was also a real handful out on the wing. Shilton was as good as Gordon Banks, he was as good as you get as a goalkeeper.”

It was a game that Pate, who was signed from Watford, remained thankful for giving him the opportunity to test himself against the very best.

“I am fortunate that the draw gave Mansfield so many ties against big teams. We played against Leeds United at Elland Road, Liverpool at Anfield, Manchester City at Maine Road, we had so many good games against so many good players. We were never humiliated in these ties and the games have given me some wonderful memories.”

Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.placeholder image
Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.

After the game relieved City boss Frank O’Farrell was full of praise for brave Mansfield.

“I thought they played well,” he said. “They gave us a hard game in what was a good cup tie, but I felt on the balance of play we deserved to win. We had better chances.

“Dave Hollins kept Mansfield in the game longer than might have been the case with some excellent saves. We needed the second goal to clinch it.”

Despite being defeated just two games away from a Wembley FA Cup final appearance, Stags boss Tom Eggleston said he was not too disappointed with the outcome.

Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.placeholder image
Mansfield Town pushed Leicester City all the way during their 1-0 FA Cup quarter-final defeat in March 1969.

“The lads did very well and I’m proud of them,”he said. “Leicester are a strong rugged side. They are not an easy side to break down and we have had a good run.”

Leicester City eventually went on to lose in the final 1-0 to Manchester City in front of a crowd of 100,000.

It capped a miserable season for Leicester, who were also relegated from the First Division after they finished second-bottom with 30 points from 42 games.

Mansfield, who earned a then record £10,550 in gate receipts, ended their Third Division campaign with a 15th place finish after winning just 16 of their 46 matches.

MANSFIELD TOWN: Hollins, Pate, Hopkinson, Quigley, Boam, Waller, Keeley, Sharkey, Ledger, Roberts, Goodfellow.

News you can trust since 1952
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice