Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Chad Careers and Jobs fair
Silver Award
Newspaper Society Weekly Website of the Year
 
 
Friday, 4th July 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Mansfield Chad site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

PAIN's threat to PCT



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Email Helen Lambourne

CAMPAIGNERS fighting plans for a waste incinerator in Rainworth could launch legal action against NHS chiefs for failing to investigate their health fears.
Members of People Against Incineration (PAIN) are considering the move against Nottinghamshire County Primary Care Trust (PCT) after bosses said it was not necessary to conduct a detailed assessment of the potential health impact of the facility.

But PAIN members say local people have genuine concerns about the effect on their health if an incinerator is built at the former Rufford Colliery site.

PAIN spokesman Shlomo Dowen told Chad: "People are not only frustrated but also distressed that our health concerns are not being addressed by anybody.

"The PCT is responsible for looking after public health. An incinerator being built in the area is a public health issue. What we are saying is that nobody has done a proper study about the impact locally on health.

'Irrational'

"Even if local people's concerns are irrational, which they are not, it is still the duty of the PCT to properly address the issues raised by local people when it comes to public health. The failing is that they are not doing their job."

Mr Dowen added that the PCT had been unwilling to meet PAIN members to discuss their concerns — so launching legal action could be the only option.

Veolia Environmental Services wants to build the incinerator to burn 180,000 tonnes of waste a year and bosses say there will be no more than a minor effect on health.

But Dr Dick van Steenis, who specialises in fighting against incinerators, claims the facilities cause health problems for those living downwind, including depression, heart attacks and an increase in infant mortality.

A spokesman for the PCT told Chad: "Nottinghamshire County Teaching Primary Care Trust has taken expert advice from the Health Protection Agency and other government agencies in relation to this application and has been in correspondence with the PAIN group.

"All reports confirm that the risks to residents who live near incinerators are exceedingly low and not measurable.

"As we are satisfied that there are no measurable health concerns associated with modern incinerator plants, we have therefore not found it necessary to undertake a detailed local health needs assessment of the potential impact of such an incinerator."

  • The next public meeting of PAIN takes place on Friday at Rainworth's Joseph Whitaker School at 6.30pm where Sherwood MP Paddy Tipping will speak. The meeting is expected to be filmed by Channel 4 for a programme about private finance initiative waste contracts.







The full article contains 427 words and appears in Mansfield Chad newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 13 May 2008 4:43 PM
  • Source: Mansfield Chad
  • Location: Mansfield
 
Prev
1
Next
1

Shlomo,

forest town, mansfield 14/05/2008 08:36:18
"All reports confirm that the risks to residents who live near incinerators are exceedingly low and not measurable." - This statement from the PCT is simply not true! We have dozens of reports that say waste incineration, even with the most modern burners, poses unacceptable risks to public health.
2

Michael Ryan,

Shrewsbury 14/05/2008 12:24:13
If the residents of Rainworth check the data in the 2006 edition of Key Population & Vital Statistics on the Office for National Statistics website, they'll find Table 4.1b lists the infant mortality rates for each of the 434 councils in the United Kingdom.

There are eight councils listed for Nottinghamshire, and the infant mortality rates for 2006 vary from 2.8 per 1,000 live births in Broxtowe to a maximum of 7.2 per 1,000 in Nottingham.

These rates are averages for each councils and the Primary Care Trusts in Notts & elsewhere will hold the birth & mortality data at electoral ward level and will know which of the 176 electoral ward in the eight council areas in Nottinghamshire had zero infant deaths in the four-year period 2003-2006 and also which wards have very high rates, such as Bridge ward, which is home to an existing incinerator and where the 2003-6 infant mortality rate is almost double the average rate for Nottingham.

The PCTs take "expert" advice from the Health Protection Agency on issues such as incinerator applications and yet the Health Protection Agency haven't bothered to examine any relevant health and mortality data in the electoral wards around any incinerator in the five years they have been in existence. Justin McCracken, the new Chief Executive of the Health Protection Agency has written to me following my Freedom of Information request and admitted in his letter dated 1 May 2008 that they've carried out no studies at electoral ward level around incinerators and that they base their opinion on the safety of incinerators upon estimates of sickness rates and also estimates of emissions. Not very scientific are they?

Kind regards,

Michael Ryan

Shrewsbury
3

Shlomo,

forest town, mansfield 18/05/2008 21:19:33
More than 100 people came to Rainworth's Joseph Whittaker School on
Friday [16th May 2008] to hear MP Paddy Tipping renew his call for a
public inquiry into the proposed waste incinerator. A formal request
is expected to be made to the Secretary of State early this summer. Mr
Tipping said he is fundamentally opposed to Nottinghamshire County
Council acting as judge and jury on the application.

At the meeting hosted by People Against Incineration (PAIN) the MP for
Sherwood outlined his reasons for opposing Veolia's proposals. He
expressed concerns that if an incinerator were built it would reverse
the trend towards increased recycling rates, and it could mean waste
would be trucked in from outside of Nottinghamshire. The facility
would be highly inefficient as it would not utilise the heat produced
and would instead contribute to increased CO2 emissions and global
warming. The planning application goes against existing plans to
restore the site to heathland and woodland for inclusion in the
Sherwood Forest Regional Park; and the proposed facility would be in
danger of contaminating the underground water (aquifer) used to supply
homes covering a large area, including Rainworth and Mansfield.

Describing the situation as "more of a marathon than a sprint", Mr
Tipping praised the efforts of local residents, and the mature and
responsible campaign that has been running for nearly two years in
Rainworth. He said the Nottinghamshire County Council's Planning
Committee may not be ready to consider the application until 2009.

In a lively question and answer session residents also raised concerns
about potential health impacts, repeating demands for local health
studies to be carried out. Participants called for a national
incineration tax to encourage more environmentally-friendly waste
treatments, such as anaerobic digestion (a form of composting).

Newark and Sherwood District Councillor Alan Tift, who chaired the
meeting, was pleased wit
4

Shlomo,

forest town, mansfield 18/05/2008 21:20:21
Newark and Sherwood District Councillor Alan Tift, who chaired the meeting, was pleased with the turnout. "It was good to host Paddy again. We were encouraged by his strong support. That so many turned up on a cold and rainy Friday evening demonstrates the commitment and
dedication of local people when it comes to opposing this incinerator. The quality of questions shows how much PAIN members have learnt about these complicated issues. The meeting left me feeling proud to be a
resident of Rainworth".

DVD recordings of the Dr Dick van Steenis talk are available for £3 (plus postage and packaging) for the 2-disc set from www.p-a-in.co.uk
Prev
1
Next

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.