Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

available car
Low priced used cars at AvailableCAR supermarket.

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Mansfield Chad site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Doctor's incinerator baby death warning


What do you think? Sign in below to have your say.

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 19 March 2008
Email Helen Lambourne

A CONTROVERSIAL doctor says plans to build a waste incinerator in Rainworth could cause serious health problems for local residents.
Dr Dick van Steenis — who specialises in fighting against incinerators — claims people living within 17 miles downwind of the facility earmarked for the former Rufford Colliery site would be at risk from suffering depression and heart attacks.

He made his shock comments to Chad after speaking to around 200 concerned residents at a public meeting held last week by protest group People Against Incineration (PAIN), which is campaigning against Veolia Environmental Services' plans to build a 180,000 tonne-per-year mixed-waste facility.

'Impacts'

"There will be a lot of people affected," he said. "Because the filtration equipment only filters out the bigger particles, they have not captured the smaller ones that get on the lungs. In the UK there has been no proper study done at all on the health impacts."

Dr van Steenis –– who is based in Wales and has successfully fought against incinerators at 26 public inquiries –– said he had carried out research showing there was a rise in baby deaths downwind of incinerators and new facilities were no better than the older ones.

He also claimed incinerators could cause a drop in IQ for children born near them.

Said PAIN spokesman Shlomo Dowen: "Up till now PAIN has underplayed the potential dangers posed to human health. Our research shows that a great deal of expertise is needed to evaluate just how dangerous these incinerators are."

But a Veolia spokesman said there had been extensive research and a report commissioned by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs had found there was no more than a minor effect on health or the environment.

Said Simon Bussell, managing director of Veolia Environmental Services Nottinghamshire: "Veolia are experts in the operation of this technology and we run 88 ERFs across the world.

"We have the knowledge and expertise to ensure that facilities operate to the highest standards with respect for the local community and environment.

"We are always willing to discuss people's concerns and will continue to work closely with the Rainworth community."

Meanwhile, it has emerged that objections to the plans have been sent to Nottinghamshire County Council from across the world from fans of Jonas Armstrong, who plays Robin Hood in the hit BBC TV series.

The fans backed the Sherwood Forest: The Living Legend bid to restore the forest and fear the impact on local habitats of the incinerator.

  • PAIN's next public meeting is at The Potters, on Kirklington Road, Rainworth, at 7pm tomorrow.


The full article contains 435 words and appears in Mansfield Chad newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 18 March 2008 3:30 PM
  • Source: Mansfield Chad
  • Location: Mansfield
 
Prev
1
Next
1

Michael Ryan,

Shrewsbury 19/03/2008 15:21:08
I don't know if there's already an "air quality management order" in force in the Mansfield area, but the following written answer to Anne Main's parliamentary question [189478] shows how highly the Department of Health regards your health and well-being.

Ms Main had asked the Secretary of State for Health "what assessment he has made of the levels of respiratory diseases in areas which are subjected to air quality management orders in the latest period for which figures are availabe; and if he will make a statement."

The reply of 4 March 2008 states:

"The Department has made no assessment of the levels of respiratory diseases in areas which are subject to air quality management orders."

Perhaps some bright spark will tell me how anyone can check the effectiveness of an air quality management order if you do not monitor the levels of respiratory diseases?

Pity it's not Viridor wanting to buikd an incinerator at Rainworth, as they've withdrawn their application to build a 450,000 tonne per annum incinerator near Dunbar, East Lothian, according to the Edinburgh Evening News of 18 March 2008 article "Incinerator plan 'up in smoke'", following Dr Dick van Steenis' appearance in the media a month ago.

I bet Dr Pat Troop, the Chief Executive of the Health Protection Agency, hasn't bothered to check any health or mortality data around any UK incinerator and yet her "experts" want local councils to "take their word for it" that there's no harm to health.

Kind regards,

Michael Ryan,
Shrewsbury

Kind regards,

Hansard is often a good source of information, so when I'd heard that Anne Main MP had asked
2

Michael Ryan,

Shrewsbury 19/03/2008 15:55:25
Why didn't Veolia come to the public meeting at Shrewsbury on 29 February 2008 when Dr Dick van Steenis was speaking about hazards of incineration?

Why is Veolia building a safer plasma gasification plant in Midland, Michigan, for Dow Corning, whilst building unsafe incinerators in the UK?

What comment has Veolia to make on the 2003 research by Chay & Greenstone, of University of California, Berkeley, and University of Chigaco respectively, which showed the fall in infant mortality rates matching the fall in airborne pollution?

Will Veoila dare publish any infant mortality data in the electoral wards around some of their English incinerators, such as Tyesely, SELCHP and Sheffield [Bernard Road] and compare the rates with somewhere with clean air, such as Ceredigion where the 2006 infant mortality rate was 1.7 per 1,000 live births?

Kind regards,

Michael Ryan,
Shrewsbury
3

James Bowlen,

20/03/2008 21:24:46
Veolia are starting to alter their stance.

They originally said that there was no risk to life whatsoever.

Now they are saying that there is "no more than a minor effect on health or the environment"

How many deaths or neo-natal abnormalities constitute a "minor effect"?
4

Phyllis Armitage,

20/03/2008 21:53:47
This was an excellent an thought provoking event and well worth attending.

I think that one of the most telling points was that, of the 200-odd attending only one County Councillor and one District Councillor attended.
It must be recorded that the County Councillor was not the one which represents Rainworth, but it was Andy Stewart from the Southwell ward. There was no sign of Yvonne Woodhead, Helen Holt or Chris Winterton (all so called Labour) who are the County Councillors who supposedly represent the people of Rainworth.

Of the three District Councillors for Newark and Sherwood and the two District Councillors for Mansfield District who represent the village only one, Alan Tift, attended. Where were Mark Buttery, Michael Jeffries, Stuart Rickersey or Roger Sutcliffe?

This shows the disdain in which all these elected officials hold their constituents.
They are meant to represent us - they only seem to want to represent their own personal point of view.
5

Jack Wilde,

20/03/2008 22:46:40
There'sone very obvious reason that Jeffries and Buttery daren't attend - their loyalty lies with Rainworth Miners Welfare and Veolia, the company wanting to put the incinerator into our back yard, have funding agreements with the Welfare now and over the coming years.

If they were to oppose the incinerator then they would be biting the hand that fed them#.
6

Michael Ryan,

Shrewsbury 21/03/2008 11:55:44
Readers of the Mansfield Chad should take heart that Veolia are fighting their "hearts & minds" incinerator campaign on several fronts, with varying success.

In Bucks, where Dr Dick van Steenis spoke at a public meeting on 24 October 2008, Veolia have brought out their "big guns" to persuade the locals that they have nothing to fear.

The Z-list celebrity they called upon to appear at a ticket-only "public meeting" was Broadcaster Johnny Ball, who "spoke in favour of the council's plands [for an incinerator]. He said: 'On this issue we must stop scare-mongering over these sites. We must move forward with the latest technology.'" [Bucks Free Press article by Hannah Williams, "Public unconvinced after public meeting", 19 March 2008.

Johnny Ball was asked how much he had been paid to attend, but lost his tongue whilst gaining colour.

The "expert" summoned by Bucks CC & Veolia to appear at the public meeting on 19 March 2008 was Professor Roy Harrison, who is mentioned as follows in Buckingham Today, 20 March 2008: "Possible health risks caused by waste incinerator emissions have also been a cause of controversy in the past, and Prof Roy Harrison from the University of Birmingham assured local residents the risks were 'negligible'".

Note that Prof Roy Harrison lives in the Stourport area of Worcestershire and the Kidderminster incinerator that would have dumped toxic PM2.5s in his back yard failed to get passed.

Also, Professor Roy Harrison assessed the Dr Catherine Woodward report about Ironbridge Power Station and agreed with her conclusion that the emissions from that installation caused no adverse health effects. Prof Harrison failed to notice that Dr Woodward had "forgotten" to examine any health or mortality data in any electoral ward upwind of the power station, despite the fact that lack of such a comparator area or a "control" set of electoral wards free from any industrial source of PM2.5s made Dr Woodwrd's report worthless.

More detail
7

Michael Ryan,

Shrewsbury 25/03/2008 12:33:48
Dr Dick van Steenis lectured on the incinerator health hazards in Surrey on 8 February 2008 and the twenty-nine bullet points of his lecture are listed at:

http://www.capelaction.org.uk/Source/WhatWhenWhere-3.htm

Kind regards,

Michael Ryan,
Shrewsbury

8

Michael Ryan,

Shrewsbury 26/08/2008 12:18:13
See the front page of Hounslow Chronicle of 21 August 2008 for latest article about my research:

http://www.hounslowchronicle.co.uk/west-london-news/local-hounslow-news/2008/08/21/baby-death-rates-soar-109642-21573869/

Kind regards,


Michael Ryan,
Shrewsbury
Prev
1
Next

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.